Property Dispute after Divorce / No Will

Scenario: A consultation was held with the eldest daughter regarding her deceased mother’s estate. The daughter approached me for legal guidance regarding a family property dispute. The Master of the High Court has formally appointed her as the Executor of her late mother’s estate.

As the Master-appointed Executor, the eldest daughter holds the sole legal authority to control and protect her late mother’s 50% share of the asset. The father retains his original 50% share. The daughters have a right of occupation and cannot be legally evicted by their father.

Under South African law, the father’s claim of sole ownership is legally incorrect. Because the couple was divorced, any automatic spousal inheritance rights ended.

Because the mother died intestate (without a will), her 50% co-ownership share of the property belongs entirely to her two daughters.

Breakdown of Property Rights

• The Husband’s Share: The ex-husband retains his original 50% co-ownership share. He cannot claim his deceased ex-wife’s half.
• The Wife’s Share: Because she died without a will (intestate), her 50% share is distributed according to the Intestate Succession Act 81 of 1987.
• The Children’s Inheritance: Under this law, the deceased’s estate is divided equally among her descendants. The two daughters inherit 25% each of the total property.

The ownership of the house is now legally split three ways
Ex-Husband 50% (His original share)
Daughter 1 25% (Inherited from Mother)
Daughter 2 25% (Inherited from Mother)

The father cannot sell the house or transfer it into his name without the daughters’ consent. The Deeds Office requires the signature of the deceased mother’s Executor to move her 50% share.

Living Arrangements and Costs

Because all three parties are now legal co-owners, the living dynamic changes significantly:

• Right of Occupation: The father has a right to live there because he owns 50%.

The daughters also have an equal right to live there because they jointly own the other 50%.

The father cannot legally evict them.

• Splitting Household Expenses: Rates, taxes, water, electricity, and general maintenance should now be divided proportionally according to ownership (50% paid by the father, and 50% split between the daughters).

What Must Happen Next

The executor/ daughter must approach a conveyancing attorney, who must formally transfer the mother’s 50% share to each daughter (25%) through the Deeds Office.

How to Resolve the Co-Ownership

Once the Title Deed is updated, the daughters and the father must agree on one of three options:
• Buy-Out: The father buys the daughters’ 50% share, or the daughters buy out the father’s 50% share.
• Sell the Property: All parties agree to sell the house and split the money (50% to the father, 25% to each daughter).
• The Rental Alternative: If the daughters choose to move out in the future, the father must pay them a market-related monthly rent for utilising their 50% share of the property.
• Forced Sale (Actio Communi Dividundo): If living together becomes impossible and the father refuses to buy them out or sell, the daughters can hire an attorney to approach the High Court. The court will order the house to be sold on the open market, and the proceeds will be split (50% to the father, 25% to each daughter).

Author's Note & Disclaimer:

The views and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author. This article was written by LSC Esterhuyse - B.Iuris LLB (Unisa), Deceased Estates Practice (Unisa), Estate Planning & Wills (UCT). The content provided here is strictly for educational and informational purposes and does not constitute formal legal advice. Readers are encouraged to consult an independent legal professional regarding their specific estate circumstances.

Comments

Understanding Executor Fees in South Africa

Losing a loved one is a difficult time, and navigating the legalities of their estate can feel overwhelming. One of the most common questions families ask is: "How much does it cost to appoint an executor?" If a Will doesn’t explicitly state what the executor should be paid, South African law provides a clear framework to ensure the process remains fair and transparent. The Prescribed Tariff: What You Need to Know Under the Administration of Estates Act, 66 of 1965 , executor remuneration is calculated using a standard tariff. This ensures that even if the Will is silent on fees, there is a legal benchmark in place. The standard rates are: 3.5% of the gross value of the estate's assets at the time of death. 6% on any income (like rental income or interest) earned after the date of death. A minimum fee of R350 (for very small estates). The "VAT Factor" in Estate Fees A common point of confusion is whether Value Added ...

Living Will

A living will is a written document in which an individual outlines their wishes regarding medical treatment if they are unable to communicate or make decisions for themselves. In South Africa, a living will is typically used to express a person's desire not to have artificial life support continued if they are terminally ill or in a permanent vegetative state. Additionally, living wills often specify that if the person is experiencing severe pain, they wish to receive medication for pain relief, even if this may unintentionally shorten their life. This approach reflects the principles of pain relief and dignity in end-of-life care, which are recognised in South African medical and ethical practice. Although South African law does not provide detailed legislation specifically governing living wills, medical practitioners generally respect such documents as expressions of a patient's wishes, provided they are clear, lawful, and consistent with accepted medical ethics. Author...

The Truth Behind the Legacy Protection Plan: The Reality of "Free" Wills

When planning your estate, you may come across financial institutions, banks, or trust companies offering to draft and store your Last Will and Testament for free. While a free Will is a legitimate service, it is critical to understand the commercial business model behind it, how it affects your estate, and the legal and financial traps tied to these plans. 1. How the "Free Will" Model Works Institutions can afford to draft Wills for free because of a specific clause hidden in the fine print: The Designated Executor: The institution names itself or its trust company as the sole, irrevocable executor of your estate. Statutory Fees: By South African law (the Administration of Estates Act ), an executor is entitled to charge up to 3.5% + VAT on the gross value of your assets, plus 6% + VAT on any income earned by the estate after death. The Policy Cross-Sell: To prevent these high fees from draining your family’s inheritance, the institution sells you a monthly...

Risks Associated with Do-It-Yourself Pro Forma Wills

The preparation of a do-it-yourself (DIY) pro forma will may, at first glance, appear straightforward and cost-effective, particularly where inexpensive templates are downloaded from the internet or purchased from stationery retailers. However, the execution of a will without appropriate professional guidance may give rise to significant legal deficiencies, potentially resulting in financial prejudice and emotional distress to surviving heirs. It is imperative that one’s passing does not become an avoidable source of hardship for loved ones merely for the sake of utilising a free or generic template. In the Republic of South Africa, the Wills Act 7 of 1953 prescribes strict formal requirements for the validity of a will. Many generic or foreign-based templates fail to comply with these statutory provisions. The use of such templates, without proper adaptation to local legislative requirements, may render the document invalid and unenforceable. D-I-Y wills frequently fail to properly ad...

Your Will must be available after you passed away.

Ensure that your original signed will is kept safe by a trustworthy person or institution, as a copy of a will is not deemed a valid will. You can also have more than one signed copy of the original will and request different trustworthy persons to keep a copy, in order to ensure that there will be an originally signed copy available after your death. Inform your family and heirs where/who is keeping a copy (or copies) of your will, so that they do not struggle to obtain it after your death. www.leonita co.za https://leonita.co.za/contactus/

Who Has the Final Say? New Developments in Burial and Tombstone Rights

The passing of a loved one often brings not only emotional grief but also complex legal disputes regarding final resting arrangements. In a significant clarification of South African common law , recent judgments have reinforced exactly where the authority lies when it comes to burial and the erection of tombstones . The Core Principle: Heirs and Executors First Under South African common law, the right and duty to bury a deceased person rests primarily with the person specifically nominated in the deceased’s will. However, in the absence of a will or clear instructions, this authority falls to the heirs and the executor of the estate . In a landmark ruling from the High Court (affirmed in April 2025), the court addressed a common friction point: Does the right to bury include the right to memorialise the grave with a tombstone?. Tombstones as an Extension of Burial Rights: The High Court clarified that the right to bury is not a one-time event. It naturally extends to the righ...

Understanding Estate Liquidity

When planning what happens to your estate after you pass away, it is easy to get caught up in who gets the family home, who inherits the vintage watch, and how to take care of the kids. But there is a silent, invisible dealbreaker in South African estate planning that can completely derail your best intentions: estate liquidity . In simple terms, liquidity is the amount of actual cash or cash-equivalents available in your deceased estate. Before your family can inherit a single cent or a piece of land, your estate has to clear its own bills. If there is no cash to pay those bills, your estate is considered "illiquid." That is when things can get incredibly stressful for your loved ones. The Hidden Trap: Control vs. Forced Sales Liquidity is the dividing line between your assets being handled on your terms, or being handled entirely on the executor’s terms. If your estate has enough cash: The executor pays off your debts, settles the taxes, hands ove...

Reporting a Deceased Estate in South Africa

Losing a loved one is an incredibly difficult time, and the added pressure of legal paperwork can feel overwhelming. In South Africa, the law requires that a deceased estate be reported to the Master of the High Court within 14 days of the date of death. To help you navigate this process, I have compiled a comprehensive checklist of the documents you will need to gather. The "Master’s Pack": Essential Forms The reporting process begins with specific forms, often referred to as the "Master’s Pack," which you can find on the Department of Justice website : Death Notice (Form J294): This contains the personal details of the deceased. Inventory (Form J243): A preliminary list of all assets (property, bank accounts, vehicles) and liabilities (debts). Next-of-Kin Affidavit (Form J192): Required if there is no valid Will to identify the heirs. Acceptance of Trust as Executor (Form J190): ...

Deceased Estates Administration

Search This Blog