When planning your estate, you may come across financial institutions,
banks, or trust companies offering to draft and store your Last
Will and Testament for free. While a free Will is a legitimate
service, it is critical to understand the commercial business model behind it,
how it affects your estate, and the legal and financial traps tied to these
plans.
1. How the "Free Will" Model Works
Institutions can afford to draft Wills for free because of a specific
clause hidden in the fine print:
The Designated Executor: The institution names itself or its trust
company as the sole, irrevocable executor of your estate.
Statutory Fees: By South
African law (the Administration
of Estates Act), an executor is entitled to charge up to 3.5% + VAT on the
gross value of your assets, plus 6% + VAT on any income earned by the estate
after death.
The Policy Cross-Sell: To prevent these high fees from draining
your family’s inheritance, the institution sells you a monthly estate
indemnity or protection policy while you are alive. This policy is
designed to cover those executor and conveyancing fees when you pass away.
2. Payouts, Surpluses, and the L&D Account
South African law protects consumers through strict transparency and
reporting requirements via the Master of the High Court:
Direct Indemnity: The monthly premium is a risk premium, not a
savings account. Upon death, the insurance amount is paid to the fiduciary
company directly to settle the estate administration costs.
The Surplus Rule: If the policy value is larger than the actual
legal fees incurred to wind up your estate, the institution cannot keep the
extra money. Any surplus must be paid out to your nominated beneficiaries or
directly into the Estate Bank Account for your heirs.
The Liquidation & Distribution (L&D) Account: The executor
must declare these transactions. The executor
fees will appear on the L&D account but will show as "settled
via indemnity cover." Because the estate did not pay these costs out of
its own pocket, they cannot be used as a deduction to lower other estate taxes.
However, the payout itself never enters the gross estate assets, meaning it
does not inflate your taxable estate value either.
3. Under South African law -
an estate's debts must always be settled before heirs can inherit
anything. If a corporate indemnity policy pays out, but the estate still faces
a financial shortfall due to massive debts and administration costs, the burden
falls strictly on the estate itself. So, it is important to remember, if
your “expensive policy” doesn’t cover all your estates expenses, this must
still be recovered from your estate!
3.1 Who Pays and Where Does the Money Come From?
The Estate Pays, Not the Family: In South Africa, beneficiaries are
not personally liable for the debts of the deceased. The debt belongs to the
legal entity known as the "Estate."
Forced Asset Liquidation: To cover the shortfall, the Executor is
legally obligated to sell off the estate's assets. This means the Executor will
auction off cars, investments, personal property, or even the family home to
raise cash for creditors.
Heirs Receive Nothing: If the sale of all assets is still not
enough to clear the shortfall, the estate is declared insolvent (bankrupt).
Creditors write off the remaining unpaid debt, but the heirs are left with an
inheritance of zero.
3.2 The Policy Only Covers Fees, Not General Debt
Limited Scope: It is critical for clients to know that a corporate
fiduciary indemnity policy only covers the Executor’s fees and
specific transfer costs. It does not cover your credit card debt, home loans,
vehicle financing, or outstanding taxes etc, so if there is a shortfall on the
policy, your estate is still liable for these expenses.
4. Comparison: Fiduciary Indemnity vs. Standard
Life Insurance
When deciding how to cover the future costs of winding up your estate,
you generally have two choices under South African law:
Option A: Fiduciary
Indemnity Policies (Corporate Plans)
How it works: A specialized insurance policy that pays the
corporate executor directly to wipe out their fees.
Key Benefits & Advantages:
It has zero Estate Duty risk because the payout bypasses the estate and
does not count toward the R3.5
million tax threshold.
It guarantees that administrative and property transfer costs are
covered without forcing heirs to sell assets.
Drawbacks & Financial Risks:
Extremely Expensive Over Time: You are overpaying for risk. A
client paying R300 a month over 30 years will hand over R108,000 in premiums
for a policy that might only pay out R70,000 in actual fees.
Zero Surrender Value: If you cancel the policy after a few years
because your financial situation changes or realize you don't need it, you lose
100% of the premiums paid. There are zero cash-back or investment value.
Fixed Maximum Fees: These plans calculate your policy size based on
the absolute maximum legal rate of 3.5% + VAT. Because the policy guarantees
they get paid this maximum amount by law, these institutions rarely offer
to discount their executor fees for your family.
The Monopoly Clause: The corporate insurer will only issue the
policy if they are named as the sole, irrevocable executor. This locks your
family into a corporate queue and strips them of the right to choose an independent
Executor later.
Option B: Standard Life Insurance (Paid to the Estate)
How it works: A standard personal life insurance policy where your
"Estate" is named as the beneficiary to provide cash liquidity.
Key Benefits & Advantages:
Complete Freedom: Your family can choose any Executor to execute
the Will.
Negotiable Fees: Independent Executors are often highly willing to
negotiate their fees down to 1.5% or 2%, leaving significantly more cash for
your heirs.
Cheaper Alternatives: If you already have a standard, independent
life insurance policy, you can simply nominate your estate or heirs as
beneficiaries to cover fees, completely bypassing the need for these corporate
plans offered to you.
The actual executor fees paid out of this cash can be used as a legal
tax deduction on the L&D account to lower other liabilities.
Limitations & Risks:
The Tax Trap: Under Section 3(3)(a) of the Estate
Duty Act, a policy paid to the estate is a "deemed asset". If
this payout pushes your total gross estate value over R3.5 million, the excess
amount is taxed at 20% Estate Duty.
The Executor is legally allowed to charge their fee on this cash payout
if it is administered through the estate account.
Summary Checklist for Decision Making
If your total estate (including life insurance) is well under R3.5
million: A standard life insurance policy or cash savings gives your
family the most freedom, allows them to choose their own independent Executor,
and allows them to negotiate lower executor fees.
If your estate is close to or over R3.5 million: Standard policies
can trigger a 20% tax liability. To protect your wealth, you should look into
structuring specialized indemnity options or naming a surviving spouse directly
as the policy beneficiary (which is 100% tax-exempt under Section
4(q) of the Estate Duty Act).
Author's Note & Disclaimer:
The views, analyses, and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of the author and are based on independent research into South African fiduciary practices and relevant statutory legislation. This article is written and drafted by LSC Esterhuyse - B.Iuris LLB (Unisa), Deceased Estates Practice (Unisa), Estate Planning & Wills (UCT). The content provided here is strictly for educational and informational purposes and does not constitute formal legal, financial, or fiduciary advice. Readers are encouraged to consult a certified financial planner or independent legal professional regarding their specific estate circumstances.
Comments
Post a Comment